Skip to Main Content
Manhattan Pension Disability Lawyers page header

Manhattan Pension Disability Lawyers

Your Employer’s Insurance Company Denied Your Claim. That Doesn’t Mean You’re Done.

You paid into this system. You worked for years, contributed to a long-term disability plan through your employer, and when the time came and you needed it, they denied you. Or they approved you initially and then cut off your benefits after a review. Or they delayed so long that you’re barely keeping the lights on while waiting for an answer that may never come.

This is not a paperwork problem. This is a legal fight, and you need a lawyer who knows how these cases actually work.

At Carey & Associates, P.C., we represent Manhattan employees navigating ERISA disability claims, including long-term disability denials, pension disputes, and benefit cutoffs. Attorney Mark Carey understands that insurance companies and plan administrators don’t deny claims by accident. They do it strategically, and they count on you not knowing how to push back. He has covered this territory extensively on the Employee Survival Guide® podcast and in dedicated deep-dives for employees who are fighting for benefits they earned.

What ERISA Is and Why It Matters

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act, known as ERISA, governs most employer-sponsored benefit plans, including long-term disability insurance, short-term disability coverage, and pension plans. If your disability benefits come through your employer’s group plan, ERISA almost certainly applies to your claim.

ERISA creates specific rights for employees, but it also creates significant challenges. Some plans give administrators discretion to interpret plan terms, and courts may defer to those interpretations. New York restricts these clauses in insured disability policies, so the standard of review depends on how your plan is funded and written. That means your fight is often not about whether you’re disabled. It’s about whether the plan administrator’s decision was reasonable, arbitrary, or made in bad faith.

That distinction matters enormously, and it’s why having an attorney who understands ERISA before you file your appeal is so important. Mark walks through the full 14-step process for navigating ERISA short-term and long-term disability claims in a dedicated Employee Survival Guide® episode that breaks down the insider strategies employees need to know to build the strongest possible record.

How ERISA Disability Claims Get Denied

Insurance companies and plan administrators have every financial incentive to deny claims and every tool to do it. Here are the patterns we see most often:

  • Relying on an in-house medical reviewer who never examined you to override your treating physician’s opinion
  • Claiming a lack of “objective medical evidence” while ignoring the documentation you submitted
  • Cutting off benefits after an initial approval period by applying a more restrictive definition of disability
  • Delaying decisions past regulatory deadlines while continuing to gather evidence against you
  • Using surveillance footage, social media monitoring, or IME results to manufacture a reason to deny

If any of these patterns sounds familiar, you are not imagining it. This is how the system operates, and understanding it is the first step toward fighting it effectively.

The ERISA/ADA/FMLA Overlap and Why It’s Complicated

One of the most important things to understand about disability claims is that ERISA rarely operates in isolation. In many cases, the same facts that support an ERISA disability claim also raise issues under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Family and Medical Leave Act.

Mark covered this intersection in depth through the story of John Fallon, a man who lost his voice box to throat cancer and then found himself fighting on three legal fronts simultaneously: his employer under the ADA and FMLA, and his disability insurer under ERISA. His case illustrates exactly why employees in serious health situations need legal counsel that understands all three frameworks, not just one.

If you were denied disability benefits and also terminated while on medical leave, both claims need to be evaluated together. The strategy for one affects the other.

What to Do Before You Miss Your Appeal Deadline

This is the most important thing you need to know: ERISA imposes strict deadlines on appeals, and missing them can permanently waive your rights. Most plans require you to file an administrative appeal within 180 days of a denial, and in many cases you cannot bring a lawsuit until you have exhausted that administrative process.

Here is what to do right now if your claim has been denied:

  • Request your complete claim file immediately. Under ERISA, you have the right to receive all the documents the plan used to make its decision. Review everything carefully. The denial letter alone is rarely the full picture.
  • Do not submit your appeal without legal help. In many cases, a court reviewing your claim is limited to the record built during the administrative appeal, so what you submit matters. What’s left out can sink your case later.
  • Act on the timeline, not your convenience. Deadlines in ERISA cases are strict and courts enforce them. Waiting until you feel ready can mean forfeiting your claim entirely.

Talk to a Manhattan ERISA Disability Lawyer Today

You earned these benefits. If an insurance company or plan administrator is standing between you and what you’re owed, that is a legal problem with legal solutions.

At Carey & Associates, P.C., we will give you a direct, confidential assessment of your claim and what your options are at every stage of the process.

Call us at (203) 255-4150 or contact us to schedule your completely confidential consultation. We represent employees across Manhattan, New York City, and throughout New York State.

Client Testimonials

quotation marks icon

Mark and his team at Carey & Associates are incredibly knowledgeable about Employment Law and have walked me through every step of the way. Their approach and guidance has been extremely effective in dealing with my case. They instill a sense of confidence by laying out the facts, caselaw, and risk assessment to help make well informed decisions. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for an Employment Attorney.

J.K.

Employee Survival Guide®

Postcast

Read More
View All

Contact us for more

Information